Information for Reviewers
Reviewer responsibilities
Invitations should be accepted only when the reviewer has suitable expertise, sufficient time and no conflict that could compromise impartiality. Reviews should be evidence-based, constructive, confidential and respectful.
Assessment criteria
- Originality, significance and alignment with the journal's scope.
- Adequacy of the literature review and clarity of the research question.
- Suitability of experimental design, theory, methods or computational approach.
- Quality of validation, error analysis, sensitivity analysis and uncertainty reporting.
- Reliability and reproducibility of findings, including data and code where appropriate.
- Soundness of interpretation, discussion, conclusions and stated limitations.
- Clarity and completeness of writing, tables, figures and references.
- Compliance with relevant ethical and reporting requirements.
Confidentiality, AI use and conflicts
Reviewers must not share unpublished manuscripts, use privileged information for personal advantage or upload manuscript files or confidential details to public generative AI services. Suspected research-integrity problems should be referred to the handling editor. Reviewers must disclose relationships that could affect objective evaluation.